During the week long competition, contestants are judged equally in three categories: appearance, personality and horsemanship. The scores from a contestant's speech presentation, photogenic judging, interviews, extemporaneous questions, introductions,  and fashion show presentation are also included. 

The horsemanship competition is a vital part of the Miss Rodeo America Pageant. Miss Rodeo America is introduced during professional rodeo performances, rides horseback in parades and makes countless other appearances where she is expected to ride an American Quarter Horse. During the competition, contestants draw for the horses they will compete on in each of the two rounds of horsemanship competition. These horses belong to Professional Rodeo Cowboys Association Stock Contractors and are unfamiliar to the contestants.

In the appearance category, contestants should be aware of what is fashionable western dress and contestants should be knowledgeable on current trends in the western wear industry. Attractiveness. Grooming--to include neatness and cleanliness in every detail. Meticulous care in general grooming is essential for a young lady to be considered for the title of Miss Rodeo America.

Intelligence and good common sense is a big factor in the personality division. Education and conversational ability in professional rodeo current events and other areas is vital, with special emphasis on grammar and enunciation. A contestant should radiate self confidence, showing maturity, high moral standards, sincerity and integrity. Miss Rodeo America pageant contestants should have the ability to project their personality, whether it be from horseback in an arena, on television, or before an audience. Also considered are sense of humor, showmanship, ambition, desire, enthusiasm and a happy outlook on life in general.